Wheeler–DeWitt Equation: Superspace, Semiclassical Limit and Lattice Constraint AlgebraResearch Paper
Motivation
The Wheeler–DeWitt equation is the quantum version of the Hamiltonian constraint of general relativity. In the canonical formulation, a spacetime is described by the evolution of the metric of a spatial slice, and Einstein's equations include a constraint: the Hamiltonian density vanishes at every point of space. Quantizing this constraint, as DeWitt did (Phys. Rev. 160, 1967), gives a second-order functional differential equation for a wavefunctional with no external time parameter.
Three structural facts make the equation distinctive:
- its kinetic term is built from an indefinite metric on the space of metrics, the DeWitt supermetric, so the equation is hyperbolic;
- the timelike direction of that supermetric is the local volume, which serves as an intrinsic time;
- in the limit , a WKB ansatz turns the equation into the Einstein–Hamilton–Jacobi equation, recovering classical general relativity.
A fourth issue is not settled: consistency. In the continuum, the Poisson bracket of two Hamiltonian constraints is a combination of the momentum constraints, so imposing all constraints is consistent (Dirac's first-class condition). Any regularization of the quantum equation, a lattice for instance, must reproduce this. Generic lattice discretizations do not: the constraints become second class (Bander 1987; Dittrich 2008; Bahr–Dittrich 2009). Whether, and with which anomaly, the Hamiltonian-constraint commutators close as the lattice is refined was singled out as an open question by Loll (Living Rev. Rel. 1998, §2.12).
The first three facts are the standard entry points of quantum geometrodynamics, as reviewed by Kiefer (arXiv 0812.0295): Section 2 for the constraints and their quantization, eqs. (3)–(8), and Section 3 for the Hamilton–Jacobi equation, eq. (10), and the semiclassical approximation, eq. (11).
Setting
A spatial metric at a point is a symmetric positive-definite matrix . Write . The DeWitt supermetric is
It is a quadratic form on symmetric momenta. Its inverse acts on velocities.
Space is represented by a finite set of sites; this is a lattice regularization. A configuration assigns to each site a matrix . All nine entries are coordinates, so configuration space is , and physical configurations are those that are symmetric and positive definite at every site. A wavefunction is a function from configurations to . The functional derivative is the partial derivative with respect to the coordinate , with the cell volume normalized to one.
The Wheeler–DeWitt operator at site , with gravitational coupling , cosmological constant , and a supplied potential playing the role of the spatial scalar curvature, is
Write for the potential at site . On the classical phase space of pairs , with conjugate to , the lattice constraints are
with the canonical Poisson bracket. They are first class if each bracket vanishes wherever all constraints vanish.
The supermetric stands to the left of both derivatives (Kiefer, eq. (7), vacuum case; the coupling is , so as in Kiefer's eq. (10)). The kinetic term involves only derivatives at the same site, as in the continuum; it is ultralocal. The potential may couple neighbouring sites.
Formalization targets
Milestones: geometry of the supermetric
- Signature. for every nonzero symmetric with , and .
- Inverse. for symmetric .
- Intrinsic time. With , and , the velocity form of the supermetric is .
Milestone: the conformal sector
For with and :
Milestone: the semiclassical limit
For every real function and :
The -independent part is the Einstein–Hamilton–Jacobi functional of Kiefer's eq. (10), Hamiltonian part, with the eikonal of the WKB form (11) (amplitude ). This is the weakest statement exhibiting the classical limit, and it holds for every potential.
Milestone: the lattice commutator
For and sites :
Milestone: the strong-coupling case
If every depends only on , then identically.
Goal: lattice constraints are second class
If the symmetric part of is nonzero at a physical , for some , then there is a point of the constraint surface over at which .
Every finite-difference curvature couples neighbouring sites, so the goal applies to every such discretization. It is the weakest statement that the discretized constraint algebra is inconsistent, and it holds uniformly in the discretization.
Stronger targets
- The limit form , as a
Tendstostatement. - The same results with the Laplace–Beltrami ordering of the kinetic term on the six-dimensional fibre of symmetric matrices, and an explicit formula for the difference between the two orderings.
- A potential realized as the scalar curvature of a smooth metric field on a coordinate patch, computed from Christoffel symbols, with its scaling law for constant .
- The momentum constraints (Kiefer, eq. (8)).
- Open as far as the drafter could determine. Fix a cubic lattice of spacing and a standard finite-difference scalar curvature. Determine the limit of the suitably rescaled commutator , and decide whether it reproduces the continuum Dirac algebra or leaves an anomaly. Give the anomaly explicitly if there is one. This is the metric-variable analogue of the question Loll raised.
Significance
The signature theorem is the mathematical content behind two physical facts: the hyperbolic character of the Wheeler–DeWitt equation, and the instability of the conformal mode (the "conformal factor problem" of Euclidean quantum gravity). DeWitt's cone form identifies the local volume as an intrinsic clock. On this rests the reading of the equation as a wave equation in superspace, with as time. The conformal-sector reduction shows explicitly how the timelike direction appears in the operator, with the sign opposite to the traceless modes. The WKB identity is the precise sense in which the quantum constraint contains classical general relativity: its leading order is the Hamilton–Jacobi form of the Einstein constraint (Peres 1962; Kiefer, eq. (10)), and its next order is the one used in derivations of the Schrödinger equation from quantum gravity.
All of these are classical computations. The drafter knows of no machine-checked version. A formalization fixes conventions that the literature handles loosely:
- the normalization of ;
- the treatment of symmetric versus independent metric components;
- the ordering of operators.
It does so with genuine derivatives in place of formal symbols.
The constraint-algebra part turns a phenomenon described qualitatively in the literature into a theorem with exact hypotheses. Lattice constraints are second class as soon as curvature couples sites, and the quantum commutator is given in closed form. It also isolates precisely what a consistent discretization would have to cancel. The continuum-limit target addresses an open question in canonical quantum gravity.
Difficulty
The supermetric statements are finite-dimensional, but none is a single computation. The signature requires a positivity argument for on an -traceless subspace. The cone form requires separating the trace part of a velocity in a non-orthonormal frame.
The analytic targets require second derivatives of compositions through the determinant and the matrix inverse. The derivative of at in the direction of a single entry is , and the derivative of produces terms like ; a sign or index slip changes the constant . Treating the nine entries as independent coordinates, rather than the six symmetric ones, changes the numerical coefficients; the conventions below fix this.
For the constraint algebra, the quantum commutator involves up to fourth derivatives of , which cancel only by the symmetry of mixed partials. The classical goal needs a point on the constraint surface where the bracket is nonzero. Each constraint fixes the value of an indefinite quadratic form in the momenta, and the bracket is linear in them, so the proof must use the Lorentzian signature to show that the bracket is not constant on that quadric.
A naive formalization that replaces by an abstract linear map reduces every target to ring arithmetic, and is ruled out by the definitions.
Formalization scope
- Definitions (module
Def_WheelerDeWittSuperspace):- metric components as
Fin 3 → Fin 3 → ℝ, so that configuration spaceX → Fin 3 → Fin 3 → ℝwithXaFintypeis a normed space; - matrices via
Matrix.of; - as
fderiv ℝ Ψ happlied to the coordinate direction of ; - as
Real.sqrtof the determinant; - the operator with the supermetric on the left.
- metric components as
- Conventions:
- all nine metric entries are independent coordinates, and statements that need symmetry assume it at the evaluation point (
Matrix.PosDefincludes symmetry); - lattice cell volume equal to ;
- vacuum (no matter term).
- all nine metric entries are independent coordinates, and statements that need symmetry assume it at the evaluation point (
- Not formalized; the potential is an interface: the potential is supplied data on configurations and sites, and every target holds for all such . The continuum limit of the lattice, a Hilbert-space domain for , regularization of coincident derivatives in the continuum, and existence of solutions are outside the mission and must not be inferred from it.
- Trivial cases to rule out:
- the WKB milestone must hold for every phase , not only for or constant ;
- the goal must exhibit a point on the full constraint surface, with every vanishing, not merely a point where the bracket is nonzero;
- the dependence hypothesis is on the symmetric part, because antisymmetric metric directions are invisible to .
- Phase-space convention: the bracket is the canonical one on all nine components per site. The symmetric reduction changes off-diagonal normalizations but not the first-class property.
- Welcome contributions: the stronger targets, a matter field with its energy density, and minisuperspace reductions (e.g. homogeneous isotropic metrics ) derived from the operator here rather than postulated.
Selected references
- B. S. DeWitt, Quantum Theory of Gravity. I. The Canonical Theory, Phys. Rev. 160 (1967), 1113–1148. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.160.1113
- C. Kiefer, Quantum Geometrodynamics: whence, whither?, Gen. Relativ. Gravit. 41 (2009), 877–901. https://arxiv.org/abs/0812.0295
- A. Peres, On Cauchy's problem in general relativity – II, Nuovo Cimento 26 (1962), 53–62. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02754342
- C. Kiefer, Quantum Gravity, 3rd ed., Oxford University Press (2012), Chapter 5. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199585205.001.0001
- R. Loll, Discrete approaches to quantum gravity in four dimensions, Living Rev. Relativ. 1 (1998), 13, Section 2.12. https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9805049
- R. Loll, On the diffeomorphism-commutators of lattice quantum gravity, Class. Quantum Grav. 15 (1998), 799–809. https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9708025
- P. Renteln, Some results of SU(2) spinorial lattice gravity, Class. Quantum Grav. 7 (1990), 493–502.
- M. Bander, Hamiltonian lattice gravity. Deformations of discrete manifolds, Phys. Rev. D 36 (1987), 2297. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.36.2297
- R. Gambini, J. Pullin, Canonical quantization of general relativity in discrete space-times, 2002. https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0206055
- B. Dittrich, Diffeomorphism symmetry in quantum gravity models, 2008. https://arxiv.org/abs/0810.3594
- B. Bahr, B. Dittrich, (Broken) Gauge symmetries and constraints in Regge calculus, 2009. https://arxiv.org/abs/0905.1670
- C. J. Isham, Some quantum field theory aspects of the superspace quantization of general relativity, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 351 (1976), 209.
- K. Pilati, Strong-coupling quantum gravity. I. Solution in a particular gauge, Phys. Rev. D 26 (1982), 2645. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.26.2645
- H. W. Hamber, R. M. Williams, Discrete Wheeler–DeWitt equation, 2011. https://arxiv.org/abs/1109.2530